To everyone’s surprise, Stephanie picked Jeff for her date. They went on a canoe ride and also had a nice meal together. They seemed to really hit it off and both commented on how easy it was to talk to each other. Jeff seemed to forget Kara’s name altogether.

Kristin and Derrick went horseback riding together and ended up having a picnic. Kristin said she had great conversations although it seemed she did all of the talking. Derrick said he wasn’t looking forward to dating her again.

Melissa picked Sterling to go on a date with. She ended up telling Sterling that she had feelings for Jerome. Sterling told Melissa to just go with her instincts even though most people are telling her not to go with Jerome.

Kara picked Giulio for her date. The date was more of a “friends” date, because neither Giulio nor Kara had any physical or emotional attraction for the other. Kara simply picked Giulio because she knew she’d have a great time with him.

Back at Luna, everyone was partying again. Michael was worried about the rift between Tiffany and Sandra. Sandra decided to lay it on the line with Michael but he was upset with how she confronted him and thought she was getting a little crazy.

He said he got along best with Tiffany and decided to stick with her. Tiffany remarked that there must be something wrong with his relationship because of how close he’s getting to her. She also said she could definitely see herself with Michael.

Anthony’s relationship with Ida was changing also. Anthony showed interest in Ashley so Ida said she was going to back off. Anthony and Ashley hung out a lot more and ended up on the hammock together late at night. Anthony put the pillow over their heads and speculation ran wild.

In the morning, the boys strolled in slowly and were told that something important was going to go down. As it happened, they had to vote off more women. Mark told the guys they had to make the numbers smaller so he asked them to vote off two of them. The boys deliberated and decided to send home Melanie and Kristin.

The two girls weren’t really fitting in with the group and they didn’t seem too disappointed to leave.

Over at Palmetto, Melissa was struggling with who she wanted to vote off. Everyone wanted Jerome to go, but Melissa was still hesitating. At the vote off, Melissa ended up saving Jerome and then broke down in tears as the girls sent home Chris to the group’s dismay.

After the vote off, Melissa and Jerome went off together to spend more time getting to know each other.

Over at Luna, the guys prepared to go to Bonfire. At the Bonfire, Mark told the guys that their women will have to watch their clips, but the guys would not. Eric decided not to watch the tape. Anthony decided to watch. He saw Stephanie hanging out more with Derrick and walking alone on the beach with him. Anthony said Derrick is nothing but Stephanie is there to find things out about herself.

Mark then asked Jason who decided to pass on watching his clip. Michael on the other hand said he wanted to see it no matter what. He saw Melissa hanging out with Jerome and he also found out that she took her necklace off. Michael said he didn’t believe the necklace thing but he can’t say for sure because he wasn’t over there.

At the Girls’ bonfire, Mark told them they have to watch a “must play” clip. The girls watched their boyfriends partying at their resort. Kristin was disappointed in seeing Eric smoke. But Melissa was the most disappointed when she saw Michael getting very close with Tiffany. She tossed her necklace into the sand and broke down crying.

Stephanie said she didn’t know what to feel though when she saw Anthony hanging out so much with Ashley.